JCCP 5431: The ChatGPT Lawsuits Before One California Judge
Last updated: November 19, 2026
When many families sue the same company over the same product, California can send all of their cases to one judge. That is what happened to the lawsuits against OpenAI over ChatGPT. In February 2026, a San Francisco judge grouped them into one proceeding, called JCCP No. 5431. This page explains what that means for a family, where the cases stand, and what comes next. It is part of our coverage of OpenAI Lawsuits.
Save the chat history first. Deleting a chat is permanent, and closing the account can erase everything at once. Leave the account as it is, then read what to do in the first days.
If you or someone you know is struggling:
- 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline: Call or text 988. Available 24/7, free, confidential.
- Crisis Text Line: Text HOME to 741741 to connect with a volunteer crisis counselor.
Talk with someone about what happened. A case review is free and confidential. Who was affected?
Free review. Submitting does not create an attorney-client relationship.
- What it is: One judge handling the ChatGPT lawsuits filed in California state court
- Court: San Francisco County Superior Court, Judge Ethan P. Schulman
- Families in the group: 21 as of November 5, 2026
- Next deadline: December 15, 2026, completed questionnaires due
- Official name: In re: ChatGPT Product Liability Cases, JCCP No. 5431
What does this mean for my family?
Grouping the cases changes how they move before trial. The parts that matter most to a family stay the same.
- Your case stays yours. Each lawsuit keeps its own family, its own facts and its own outcome. Nobody is signed up automatically.
- You keep your own lawyer. A small group of law firms handles the work every case shares, like gathering OpenAI’s records. Each family’s own lawyer still handles their case.
- Only your family can settle your case. The judge’s order says each family alone decides whether to accept a settlement.
- You do not need to live in California. The group takes cases filed in California state court, wherever the family lives. Families from Nevada, Texas, Georgia and Canada are already in it.
- You can ask to keep your name private. Families can ask the court to let them sue under a different name, such as Jane Doe. Two families in these cases have done that.
Whether a particular family’s case could join depends on the facts. A lawyer can look at those facts with you.
Not sure whether this applies to your family? A free, confidential case review through Lawsuit Center is a way to find out. There is no cost and no obligation, and submitting a request does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Not sure where to start? Read the first steps for a family considering a ChatGPT lawsuit.
What are the families suing over?
Most of these lawsuits were brought by families after someone they loved died. Others were brought by people who survived a mental health crisis. The complaints say the person spent months talking with ChatGPT, and that the product kept engaging when it should have stopped.
The families argue that ChatGPT is a product, so the rules for dangerous products should apply. Under those rules, the questions become whether a safer version was possible and whether users were warned. OpenAI disputes the allegations, and no court has decided them.
The families ask for money for the death or the injury. Several also ask the court to order changes to how ChatGPT responds to a person in crisis.
Who is in the group?
As of November 5, 2026, 21 lawsuits are in the group, and 12 more have been filed and could still join. They include Raine v. OpenAI, the first case of its kind, and Winters v. OpenAI, brought by a man who nearly died after following ChatGPT’s health advice.
To find a case like your family’s, see the filed cases grouped by what happened. Every case in the group is listed by name and number in the case list below.
Where do things stand?
The judge has set the first steps for every case. Families are now getting their ChatGPT records back from OpenAI. By November 5, 2026, OpenAI had sent records in 15 of the 21 cases.
The records go to each family’s lawyers through a secure link. They include the chats, voice transcripts, uploaded files and saved memories. They also include the flags and actions OpenAI’s safety systems applied to the account.
A hearing was set for November 13, 2026. Both sides wanted Judge Schulman to use it to settle the ground rules for gathering evidence, including the questionnaire every family fills out.
What would my family be asked to share?
Every family in the group fills out a questionnaire, called a fact sheet. A family fills it out with their lawyer. Both sides use the answers to choose the first cases for trial.
The questionnaire asks how the person used ChatGPT, what harm followed and when it began. It also asks about doctors, treatment and medications, going back seven years before the person first used ChatGPT. The answers go to the lawyers in the case, and the court is setting rules for keeping records like these confidential.
OpenAI has asked the judge to make the questionnaire broader. Its version would also ask about past abuse, run-ins with police, drug or alcohol use, and other apps the person used. The families’ lawyers say those questions should wait until a case is chosen for trial. Judge Schulman will decide what the questionnaire asks.
Completed questionnaires are due December 15, 2026. A family’s lawyer handles that deadline and helps with each answer.
What happens next?
Cases like these move in stages, and each stage takes months.
- Families review the records. Lawyers go through the ChatGPT records with each family. Families can update their lawsuits after reading them, by November 16, 2026.
- Both sides exchange information. Families send their questionnaires, and OpenAI answers its own set of questions and hands over records.
- A few cases are chosen to go first. The judge and the lawyers pick a small number of cases for the first trials. These are often called bellwether cases, and their results help everyone see how the rest might go.
- The first trials. Those cases go to trial unless they settle first. No trial date has been set yet.
Along the way, Judge Schulman will also rule on OpenAI’s legal challenges to the claims. The biggest is whether ChatGPT counts as a product under the rules for dangerous products. That ruling will shape every case in the group. We explain the question in Is AI Output a Product or Content?
Why are these cases in California?
OpenAI is based in San Francisco and Sam Altman lives in California, so families from anywhere can sue them there. A case filed in California state court against a company based in California stays in state court. OpenAI cannot move it to federal court.
Raine was brought by a California family and Turner-Scott by a Texas family. Shamblin was brought by parents in Nevada, and Lacey by a father in Georgia. Carrier was brought by a mother in Canada.
Where a case lands depends mostly on where the family’s lawyers choose to file it. The Tumbler Ridge lawsuits are in federal court in San Francisco instead. Those families and survivors are Canadian, and someone from another country suing an American company can choose federal court. Their lawyers did.
Common Questions
Is JCCP 5431 a class action?
No. A coordination proceeding groups individual lawsuits before one judge for everything before trial. Each case keeps its own plaintiffs, its own facts, and its own outcome. No one is automatically included, and there is no shared settlement fund unless one is later negotiated.
How does a family's case join JCCP 5431?
A case joins after it is filed in California state court and the family's lawyer asks the judge to add it. Whether a particular case fits depends on the facts.
Does a family have to live in California for its case to be part of JCCP 5431?
No. The group takes in ChatGPT cases filed in California state court, wherever the family lives. OpenAI is based in San Francisco, so families from other states and countries can sue there. Families from Nevada, Texas, Georgia and Canada already have cases in the group. Whether a particular family's case belongs there depends on the facts.
Will our family's name be public?
Lawsuits are public records. A family can ask the court to let them sue under a different name, such as Jane Doe, and two families in these cases have done that. Whether that fits a family is something to raise with a lawyer.
How many ChatGPT lawsuits are in JCCP 5431?
Twenty-one, as of a joint filing by both sides on November 5, 2026. Thirty-three cases have been filed in all, so twelve more could still join.
Is a JCCP the same as an MDL?
It is the California state-court version. An MDL groups federal cases, and a JCCP groups California state cases. Both handle everything before trial together while leaving each case separate. See MDL Basics.
Does coordination change what an individual family must prove?
No. Each family still has to prove the same things. What changes is how the case is handled before trial. One judge oversees it, evidence is exchanged once for everyone, and the big legal questions get one ruling.
Case List and Schedule
This section is for readers looking up the court record. The court’s order says JCCP No. 5431. Some press releases and news stories give the number as “JCCP 5341,” and a search under that number finds nothing.
All 21 cases in the group, as of November 5, 2026
- Raine, for Adam Raine (CGC-25-628528)
- Brooks (25STCV32386)
- Enneking, for Joshua Enneking (CGC-25-630809)
- Fox, for Joe Ceccanti (25STCV32379)
- Irwin (CGC-25-630811)
- Lacey, for Amaurie Lacey (CGC-25-630808)
- Madden (25STCV32383)
- Shamblin, for Zane Shamblin (25STCV32382)
- First County Bank, for Suzanne Adams (CGC-25-631477)
- Gray, for Austin Gordon (26STCV00988)
- Jacquez (26CV165635)
- DeCruise (26CU003118C)
- Knowlton and Routt, for Taylor Rose Knowlton (CGC-26-633067)
- Lantieri (CGC-26-634445)
- Chesterton (CGC-26-634698)
- A Jane Doe action (CGC-26-635725)
- Turner-Scott and Scott, for Samuel Nelson (CGC-26-636801)
- Arnstad, for TJ Arnstad (CGC-26-637159)
- Carrier, for Alice Carrier (CGC-26-637791)
- A self-represented plaintiff’s case, added July 21, 2026 (CGC-26-636564)
- Parish, for Christian Faith Madison (CGC-26-637986)
12 cases that could still join
Requests to add Jean Doe and Rosenthal are waiting on the judge. For the other ten, the lawyers on both sides are still discussing whether they should join.
- Jean Doe (CGC-26-639036)
- Rosenthal (CGC-26-641465)
- Lines, filed July 1, 2026
- Nadia N., for M.N., filed July 22
- Winters, filed August 3
- Habib, for Mathias Habib, filed October 14
- Gates, filed October 14
- Hill, filed October 14
- Works, filed October 14
- Wan, for Bowen Wan, filed October 27
- Feinberg, for Aleksandr Feinberg, filed October 29. It also sues Luka, Inc., the company behind the Replika chatbot.
- Aerenlund, filed November 2
The court’s schedule for every case in the group:
- November 13, 2026. Hearing set on the ground rules for evidence, including the family questionnaire.
- November 16, 2026. Deadline for families to update their lawsuits after reading the ChatGPT records.
- December 15, 2026. Completed questionnaires due from both sides.
- December 16, 2026. The defendants’ responses due to the updated lawsuits.
On August 4, 2026, Judge Schulman put four law firms in charge of the work every case shares. Microsoft is also named in four of the cases and has its own lawyers. Lawsuit Intelligencer covers the litigation side of these cases for lawyers and the industry, starting with Inside the AI Wrongful Death Docket.
Sources
- Order re Petition for Coordination, JCCP No. 5431 — the signed order that created the proceeding.
- The same order, hosted by Reason — a second copy from a source outside the cases.
- San Francisco County Superior Court, ChatGPT Product Liability Cases, No. CJC-25-005431, Joint Case Management Statement (filed November 5, 2026) — the case list, the records sent so far and both sides’ questionnaire proposals.
- San Francisco County Superior Court, ChatGPT Product Liability Cases, No. CJC-25-005431, Case Management Order re Production of User Account Information (signed October 28, filed October 30, 2026) — how the ChatGPT records are handed over.
- The complaints in Raine, Lacey, Shamblin, Carrier and Turner-Scott, filed in California state court — where each family lives.
- OpenAI Help Center: How to delete and archive chats in ChatGPT
The lawsuits described here make allegations. OpenAI disputes them, and no court has decided them. Grouping the cases is how the court manages them, and each case is decided on its own facts.
Request a Case Review
Attorney Advertising. Lawsuit Informer is operated by a California-licensed attorney. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
If ChatGPT may have played a part in harm to you or someone in your family, you can request a free case review on Lawsuit Center.
Request a Case Review →Educational purposes only. Submitting the form on Lawsuit Center does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Related Coverage
OpenAI Lawsuits
The full case tracker: every OpenAI lawsuit, the theories behind them, and current status.
Raine v. OpenAI
The foundational wrongful death case, from the original complaint to the current fight.
Tumbler Ridge Lawsuits
The federal suits filed after the Tumbler Ridge school shooting.
Garcia v. Character Technologies
The chatbot case where product liability claims survived dismissal.
Is AI Output a Product or Content?
The legal question that will decide how far these cases go.